It is too early to open a bottle of Champagne!

  • Created on Saturday, 17 March 2012 12:49
  • Published on Saturday, 17 March 2012 12:49
  • Written by Punyatma Sharan, Founder/CEO - PolityIndia.Com, has a BA (Political Science) from India and MBA (Finance) from USA.

champagne_smIt was a good day for UP and even a better day for India when the results were announced last week for the UP assembly elections.

Mayawati, the former chief minister, who had a zero asset base when she joined politics and who is worth Rs. 111.64 crores today was kicked out of the office by the public and they brought Samajwadi party back into power with a thumping majority. Mayawati, who claims to represent the poorest of the state's poor Dalits was worth Rs. 52.27 crores in 2007 and Rs. 88 crores in 2010. Even though Mulayam Singh Yadav's Samajwadi party led by his son Akhilesh Yadav recorded a massive victory by winning 224 out of 403 seats, it would be a fair statement to make that it was basically more a vote against Mayawati and less a vote for Samajwadi party. It was a vote against corruption and misrule.

The public definitely showed their positive feelings for Akhilesh Yadav who worked very hard to win the confidence of the public and making a connection with them. There is no doubt that it was also a victory for Akhilesh Yadav. It is a welcome change that someone like him who has a very good educational background and whose statements resonate with the requirements of the modern society and who also got a chance to get some prudent political training is at the helm of affairs.   

Even though I am against dynastic politics, I am very much in support of Akhilesh Yadav. Some people try to use his foreign education to go against him. He is not only foreign educated but he had a decent education before he went to Australia. It is a disservice to Akhilesh to call him foreign-educated. He has a Sainik school education - still considered in many parts of India as the most disciplined schooling that a young boy can get. He studied at the Sainik School in Dhaulpur, Rajasthan. Akhilesh then did his Bachelor of Engineering and Masters of Engineering in Civil Environment Engineering at the University of Mysore in Karnataka. Only then did he get his "foreign education" - a Masters degree in environmental engineering from the University of Sydney in Australia.

When Samajwadi party got only 24 seats in 2009 parliamentary elections (11 short of 2004 elections), the father turned to the son for the resuscitation of the party. In June 2009, Akhilesh Yadav was made the president of the party. On his way to the spectacular victory of March 6, 2012, the younger Yadav had to remodel the party's image, step on many toes, pump in ideas that seemed antithetical to the SP way of thinking.
Since UP is the largest state in the country with 80 Lok Sabha seats and the assembly election results was perceived as a precursor to the 2014 parliamentary elections, all the political parties descended on the state with their star campaigners. All of them worked very hard and the public weighed their options and instead of UP getting a hung assembly, they were pragmatic enough to vote just one party in power. They not only  defeated Mayawati but also went for a stable government. The hard work of Akhilesh Yadav over the last year or so paid off when his party got a record 224 out of 403 seats. The quintessential local boy, who was born here and has learnt his politics on the dusty '˜kuchcha' roads of the UP heartland, is the new UP Chief Minister. Akhilesh traveled about 10,000 km and held 800 rallies in UP over the last six months. 

Even though Mayawati lost the elections, she came back with an impressive number of 80 seats. On the other hand, both the so called national parties just could not sell their message and ended up with just 47 seats (BJP) and 37 seats (Congress). The most humiliating defeat was for the BJP candidate in Ayodhya, the proposed site for Ram Mandir, when  BJP's Lallu Singh, who was winning the seat since 1991 state elections, lost to a young student leader Tej Narain Pandey of Samajwadi Party with a margin of about 5,700 votes. BJP lost the temple town of Ayodhya, considered to be its bastion since 1991, from where it spearheaded the Ram temple movement which catapulted the party into power at the Centre. A very severe humiliation was also inflicted on the Congress party when they lost 8 of the 10 assembly seats of Rae Bareli and Amethi which are a part of the parliamentary seats for Sonia Gandhi and Rahul Gandhi. Even a day before the counting of votes, Priyanka Gandhi was claiming to get 10 out of 10 seats in Rae Bareli and Amethi.

There is no doubt that the election results in UP is sending a message to the entire country, loud and clear, that the role of religion in politics is as unacceptable as the role of the Gandhi family as a political dynasty. The young India wants a total separation of religion from politics. Sonia Gandhi and Rahul Gandhi campaigned with full zeal in Bihar in 2010 and UP in 2012 and they got only 4 seats (4 out of 243) in Bihar and 37 (37 out of 403) in UP. Rahul Gandhi's theatrics of going to Dalit families and having food with them did not impress them enough to vote for his party. The way Rahul Gandhi was going to Dalit families to share their food, I would not be surprised if the mothers were forcing their children to have the food as soon as it was cooked because they were scared that Rahul baba (a nickname given to him by the sycophants of his party) would come and not only eat their food but also ask for their vote.

They liked Priyanka Gandhi's appearance but again, not strong enough to vote for her party. It seems that the political dynasty of the family is on its last legs. The brand name Gandhi has lost its value and their claim to rule the country has been deemed malafide by the Indian public. The country has grown and matured politically and the prince and princess of the party may have to look for another profession. A senior member of the party told me that some members of the party would do their best to keep the Gandhi name alive in politics because it gives them their '˜roji-roti'. I feel that it is a little too late to bring Priyanka Gandhi in as a full time politician because the public perception would be that since Rahul failed miserably, the party is now imposing Priyanka on us.

The massive mandate for Akhilesh Yadav is a mandate for accountability, governance and transparency. I must congratulate Mulayam Singh Yadav for letting Akhilesh become the CM because he was perceived as an agent of change and face of the party and if Mulayam had become the CM, it would have betrayed the confidence of the public. Moreover, there are some bad memories associated with Mulayam's rule in UP. We cannot talk of change and have the status quo government. This election has the potential to change the political paradigm and political landscape of the country. The country is counting on people like Akhilesh to give politics a good name. He should stay away from sycophants and political chamchas who use their political contacts to make money...He should stay away from the breed of those bureaucrats who concentrate less on their professional duties and more on hobnobbing with politicians to get a posting of their choice and make money...I know bureaucrats who spends so much time with politicians that it is hard to fathom that they are bureaucrats and not politicians.

I can understand people with not much education trying to ride the coattails of a politician to make money but it is sheer pathetic to see a person coming through the UPSC exam to become a '˜darbari' of a politician. It is even more ironical that these kind of morally bankrupt people do not miss a chance to give a speech on character and morality. The key word for Akhilesh should be deliverance...there should be no room for mediocrity. There should be no political vendetta against Mayawati...she messed up and the public punished her. Our politicians are '˜Batton ke Badshah', Akhilesh has to do things to change this perception. He should not bask in the glory of the election results. The same public which elevated him to become the CM can also bring him down.

Efficiency is a relative term but honesty is not. He should not compromise at all on honesty and transparency in his administration. It is very sad that a global magazine called Business Insider has named 23 richest politicians in the world and they have ranked Sonia Gandhi as number 4 saying that her assets could be as high as $19 billion. The quantitative aspect of the election process is over and he got 224 seats...he has to now concentrate on the qualitative aspect and deliver. He has to translate the quantitative aspect to bring the state out of a political morass. It is now essential to change the political character of the country...we need a complete revolution of our political system and states like UP, Bihar and others could be the launching pad for this arduous task. We wish Akhilesh Yadav and his team all the best on this difficult and challenging journey.

Akhilesh Yadav has a very big task on his shoulders and even though he is entitled to some celebration, it is too early to open a bottle of champagne.


# Ajay Gupta 2012-03-17 15:24
Mulayam's government has been given a second chance by the UP population (whether because of lack of alternatives or people really believe in 'second chances') and they should strive to make the most of it. I am glad that Mulayam let his son take the reins (deservedly so) and hopefully he will not disappoint the folks in UP. He has made a good start by removing 10 of his party members for creating trouble after the election victory. Hope he keeps this trajectory and takes UP out of the mess it is in today. It will be no mean task and I wish him all the best (he will need many such wishes).
# Ajay Kumar Sinha 2012-03-18 05:06
I agree with you that it is too early to call for bottle of champange but I beg to differ with you on wealth of both the leaders of UP. Maya and Mulayam were both poppers before they came into politics and both have amassed wealth after coming to power. Mulayam too is one of the richest politicians in India and Maya has already declared part of her wealth. So lets not talk about who is rich and who is poor in Indian politics. Akhilesh has Indian and Australian degrees but whether he is educated or not, I have my doubts. One can purchase degrees but not education. Maya still holds her dalit votes and Mulayam is OBC this time. Muslims have voted in block in favour of SP which gives them advantage of 4% over BSP. Maya is still young and you cannot write her off. As regards the national parties, they have no future in state politics as they are far away from local issues and they do not have organisational structure to run state politics. Take the example of Prakash Singh Badal, he knows all his workers by first name and communicates with them directly. This is called party working. Lets hope the SP performs and we will call for the bottle after 365 days.
# Dr Chirag A Shah 2012-03-18 09:26
Good article. Let us hope religion and dynasty will be replaced by delivering what people need, as done in Gujarat to a large extent by Modi and BJP.
# Sanjay Pawar 2012-03-18 20:50
Akhilesh Yadav has the right credentials. He should be very tough because the old timers in his own party would try to create problems for him. There are some people who would try to get more than they deserve and would use chamchagiri as well as other tricks in the book and Akhilesh has to deal with them with an iron hand. If he is unable to do this, he would become just another politician. I agree with you that the Gandhi family's game in Indian politics is coming to an end. You are right about some bureaucrats. I come from a political family and I have dealt with them on a personal basis. Some people have just no shame and self respect and would do anything to move up in life.
# Dhananjay Singh 2012-03-18 20:56
A great article. I disagree with Ajay Kumar Sinha about Akhilesh Yadav's education. If a rich person goes out to buy a degree, they do not buy three degrees, they just buy one. I have seen him speaking and he is undoubtedly a very intelligent person. Mr.Sinha, please give the credit where the credit is due.
# Kalpana Rastogi 2012-03-19 10:57
Are we expecting a bit too much...will he be able to deliver....lets wait and watch. He received acclaim for denying ticket to a criminal and yet when the ministry was formed, another was made a cabinet minister. I have heard him speak to a good many people on TV, being interviewed by the big names on TV and he did talk a lot of sense but the problem is implementation. He is already facing the teething problems and is finding it difficult to maintain law and order but we have to give him time(within the time frame). He needs to deal with an iron hand and needs to crush the ambitions of his so called uncles in the party and outside who have seen him grow to an adult in front of them and he has to prove himself beyond his age.
# Anushka Sharma 2012-03-20 19:51
There is no doubt that Indian politics is changing for the better. The average quality of our politicians is so poor that it will take some time but the process has started. We got to have some more people in politics with good quality education. A decent education does not only give a degree, it also opens up your thought process.
# Dr Anita Sinha 2012-03-20 19:59
I agree with you that the election of Akhilesh Yadav would set a new tone in Indian politics. I am sure that the 2014 parliamentary election would see a lot of very good people. The political parties can't afford to give party tickets to people with a shady background.
# Santosh Singh 2012-03-20 20:05
The days of Congress and BJP is over. We have entered an era where the regional parties would decide the national politics. I would not be surprised if the PM is also selected from the regional parties.
# Kalpana Singh 2012-03-22 11:20
Akhilesh Yadav has all the ingredients to make a difference. The biggest problem is the old timers which includes people like Azam Khan and Akhilesh's uncle who are interested to become the CM. If they can have their way while Akhilesh is the CM, they would stay quiet. If not, they would create a lot of problems for him. Akhilesh should be ready for the second scenario.
# Deepak Mathur 2012-03-22 11:26
Some of us are overestimating the power of the senior leaders of the party. Akhilesh Yadav should know that it was a vote for change and his ideas and he should not be scared to be tough while dealing with them. The public is with him and not with the senior leaders of the party.
# Rakhee Sharma 2012-03-23 15:01
I have a good feeling about the style of governance in UP. Akhilesh Yadav always comes out to be a very pragmatic and very down to earth person. These two qualities would really help him to deal with the situation.
# Mukta Dhar 2012-03-23 15:11
A very detailed and a very analytical article. Punyatma, another great job. I am counting on three chief ministers who would bring some serious changes in Indian politics. They are Narendra Modi, Nitish Kumar and Akhilesh Yadav. Narendra Modi's hands are tied because of his association with BJP. He should leave BJP and go on his own...BJP needs him, he goes not need BJP. The present BJP central leadership with no strong leader would never allow him to become a part of national politics...they are just too scared of his popularity.
# Anamika Mishra 2012-03-28 18:16
I am very happy about one thing in UP elections. We are in the process of getting MUKTI from the stupidity of the Gandhi family. It is about time for us to be Gandhi-free.
# Vinay & Anu Mahajan 2012-03-28 18:22
We want you to know that this website is helping to change the mindset of a lot of people. The articles are so detailed and your thinking is so much out of the box that it is forcing people to think. We also got a transcript of your speech in Singapore and it was very impressive.
# Sujata Singh 2012-03-28 18:27
We should all wish for Akhilesh Yadav's success. His administrative success in UP would be a stepping stone for the success of new India where people like Mayawati, Lalu and others would have no political future.


Ram Nath Kovind

Ram Nath Kovind (born 1 October, 1945) is the 14th President of the Republic of India. He was sworn in as President of India on 25 July, 2017 succeeding Pranab Mukherjee.


Prime Minister

narendra modi

Narendra Modi (born 17 September, 1950) is the 15th Prime Minister of the Republic of India. He was sworn in as the Prime Minister on 26 May, 2014 succeeding Dr Manmohan Singh.


Manifesto (Congress)


2014 Elections


Manifesto (BJP)

Manifesto (AAP)